A Show of Hands
September 18, 2008
by James Taranto
NEW YORK–The other night we attended the first-of-the-season Intelligence Squared debate. We’ve been going to these for a while and always find them interesting and stimulating. This week’s topic was health-care policy, and one of the panelists arguing for more federal control was former Enron adviser Paul Krugman.
At one point, Krugman asked for a show of hands in order to prove a point, but it didn’t turn out as he expected (see pages 43-44 of the transcript; ABC’s John Donvan was the moderator):
Krugman: –and I wanted to ask, actually two questions, to the audience. First, how many Canadians, would Canadians in the room please raise your hands. [One person applauds, laughter]
Donvan: We have about seven hands going up—
Krugman: OK, not as many as I thought. OK, of those of you who are not on the panel who are Canadians, how many of you think you have a terrible health care system. [pause] One, two–
Donvan: We see—almost all of the same hands going up. [laughter]
Krugman: Bad move on my part [applause]. I’ve got a selected–all right, I won’t try it. But I will say, that–
We never did find out what Krugman was going to say, though it appears he was alluding to a selection bias that affected the sample of Canadians in the audience. We don’t usually agree with Krugman, but we have to admit, he had a point. The Canadians in the audience could not be representative of their countrymen. Just that they were in America meant that they were lucky enough to get out alive.